Trade Idea – Tractor Supply Company

As we all know from Ocean’s trilogy, playing a story once again is probably not the best. In case of Tractor Supply Co. this feeling has been underlined by different segment and company specific factors as well:

  • The outlook of the classic US retail players have been weakened mainly due to the increasing dominance of e-commerce business models. Year-to-date number on retail store closures is already outpacing that of 2008 (year of latest recession in the States) and appr. 2,880 have been announced so far this year according to Credit Suisse.
  • TSCO’s share price dropped significantly and its valuation (and its expected dividend yield) is far more expensive compared to its peers.



Historical share price performance of Tractor Supply Company, source: Yahoo Finance


On the other hand the low-debt company could offer some locked in potential. Based on the analysts’ consensus the long-term growth prospects remain roboust despite the disappointing quarterly performance and the 12m projected share price might offer more than 20% return.

Considering all these pros and cons a new long position in TSCO has been opened at USD 53 on 24 May 2017.


Trade Idea – Macy’s


On 9 January 2017 long position opened in Macy’s at USD 30.52.

The share price of Macy’s – one of the biggest retailer in the US and has appr. USD 10 bn market cap – decreased significantly after the CEO anticipated that sales values would be stronger (especially the watches and handbags segments delivered weak results). The envisaged OPEX cut initiatives are expected to result in more than half billion USD savings per year.


Historical share price development of Macy’s (USD), source: Yahoo Finance


Historical profitability metrics (mn USD), source: company reports

Key investment considerations:

  • the falling share price pushed the RSI into the oversold territory from technical perspective
  • current fundamental trends seem to be disadvantageous, however majority of the analysts maintained buy or hold recommendation in respect to the stock
  • over 4% expected dividend yield

Year Ahead 2017

Where are we in the business cycle?


(1) Year 2016 in review

Without any doubt the previous twelve months were the year of surprises from many perspectives. Despite its pre-season odds of 5000/1 Leicester won the Premier League, however there were some solid examples from the investing markets as well. (i) Britain’s decision to leave the EU and the election of Donald Trump as the president of US caused unexpected movements on the market in both directions. (ii) Many called into question the reliability of the pollsters because these events were considered as underdog outcomes based on the surveys. (iii) And the Chinese economy didn’t turned into recession (this was one of the key risk factors of market forecasts) in 2016.


Historical performance of MSCI World index (source:Yahoo Finance)

As per IMF data, global economy is ecpected to grow by above 3% in 2016 and in 2017 as well. Not a surpise, increasing consumption was fuelled by real wage growth. In general global equity markets were oscillating in a range for almost three years from now (with US outperforming rest of the world).

The top FX story was the strenghtening dollar in 2016.

The extremely lazy global monetary policies pushed down mainly every debt related metrics, which was favourable for borrowers (the improved credit conditions are underlined by falling credit spreads; era of “easy money” with gradually increasing debt levels), on the other hand even nominal returns were hard to achieve on the fixed income markets. Practically real assets and equities were able to generate some noteable returns; the increased demand in these asset classes resulted in significantly increased valuations (US equity market, real estate prices in developed cities).

Additionally the investors could have learnt again last year that uncertanties in connections with politics and elections can have greater impact on the markets. This risk factor can be as significant as “simple” market risks we they are familiar with.

What will happen in 2017? Although we strive for one-handed answers, our current investment universe might not allow it. In the next section I will summarize my thougths on the key themes.

(2) Key investment themes

(2.1) US monetary policy

Majority of the investors already priced in the effects of Fed’s “gradual” rate hiking policy. Undoubtedly the recent US macro figures are supportive: in H2 inflation increased moderately and GDP data confirmed economic growth. The monetary tightening is expected to result in – finally – remarkable US yields and further appreciating dollar in 2017.


Historical US Treasury yields for different maturities (source: US Treasury)

The key question for the next decades whether this momentum might be new inflection point of US historical yield graph and a new upward trend could start. And why is this important? Because the increasing US bond price curve was one of the most important fundamentum of the last three decades from investors’ perspective.

Additionally the yield curve became more steepener, which – together with the stimulative fiscal regime (see next section) – is supportive for economic growth.


Long – short term US yield differences (source: US Treasury)

(2.2) Fiscal support

This would be quite a new policy item on the post 2008 developed markets. Based on Trump’s announcements tax cuts and increased spendings in infrastructure and defence segments are expected in the US. An additional potential impact which could put an upward pressure on inflation and growth (causing further monetary tighthening). In Europe such magnitude of fiscal easing seems to be less certain.

(2.3) Eurozone monetary policy

Most probably ECB will change the QE and will follow the FED in central rate hike (at least back to positive territory) – with a certain time lag. It would be very hard to imagine that Eurozone could do the opposite strategy compared to US on long term. Very intersesting to see the significant differences between the two yield curves for all maturities.


US and Eurozone yield curves on 30 December 2016 (source: ECB, US Treasury)

(2.4) End of deflanatory threats

Based on OECD forecasts the expected inflation rates for US, Eurozone and OECD countries are 1.9%, 1.2% and 1.8% respectively. The relatvely long era of disinflation seems to over.

(2.5) Special risk factors might completely reshape forecasts

  • European elections: The Eurozone election calendar seems to be very complex in 2017 (the Netherlands, France, Germany). Similar to pre-Brexit odds the base case for investors might be the “no surprise” outcome, however increased level of volatility is expected.
  • Equity valuations: compared to historical limits, this asset class is definitely not cheap. Additionally the stricter monetary policies are not necessarily supporting equites.
  • Real estate bubbles: extreme price levels already in central cities of developed world.
  • Current stage of the business cycle: In the theory the increasing level of inflation and the stricter monetary policy could be the early indicators for an upcoming economic slowdown (mid or long term). It is worth to mention that the current business cycle is 7 years old already.
  • Chinese growth related considerations similarly to 2016 forecasts. FX reserves are in a declining trend and CNY depreciated significantly against the dollar.

(2.6) Asset allocation ideas

  • Due to the existing stimulative monetary policy and growing economy, European equities can outperform this year. Long position in the related instruments (Eurostoxx or other index derivatives) seems to be reasonable.
  • The US equity market can easily grow further, but the “gradually” restrictive monetary policy might put a downward pressure on it. Not necessarily a clear picture for US equities, but countinous monitoring of technically¬†oversold securities is proposed.
  • Do not have a clear opinion about gowth vs value stocks. In the light of potential slowdown in mid term, investor might turn to the value stocks.
  • Due the uncertainties related to Brexit, having no clear opinion on UK equities.
  • The strengthening dollar and the rising bond yields are not really supportive for emerging market equities. Isn’t a clear picture.
  • Bond funds might not overperform due to the downward pressure on bond instruments.
  • With really small bets certain emerging markets with recent shocks (i.e. Turkey) can be tapered. Remember on post-Brexit reactions or the Russian stock market opportunities, when investors could utilize the short term volatilities.
  • Corporates with outstanding USD debt obligation having no sufficient dollar income as natural hedge seem to face increasing debt service costs. Rather avoid of these assets.
  • On the FX side everybody’s favorite is the USD, but further upsides might be limited in case other regions will start to follow restricting monetary policies.

Backtesting 2015/2016

As the beginning of 2017 approaches majority of the people start summarizing the notable events that are important to them. For example there are dozens of rankings about movies, surprising sport events and famous people. The financial professionals select the top stories of this year from the global investment universe and traders calculate their individual performance hoping for nice bonus levels.

Similar to these in this post I collected the realized outcomes and the currently unrealized values of my recent trade ideas. Thanks to the conservative investment policy I follow all of the initiated positions resulted in a profit. On the other hand the 1-2% holding period returns were often due to the strict stop loss limits. The biggest gain was generated by the Pernod Ricard position (16% over the holding period, 73% in annualized terms).

Additionally the currently unrealized Aegon shares in the portfolio are performing really nicely as well.


The highlighted holding period returns are not annualized and are generated from long positions in the equities and do not contain dividend returns received over the holding period. All return values are before fees and taxes.